Use cases and AI confidentiality in law firms: what leaves when client files go into ChatGPT or Claude.

The regulators have said it plainly: confidential, sensitive or privileged client information cannot safely be entered into publicly available AI chatbots. What that looks like in practice is less often shown. This series takes 97 documents a law firm produces every week, from the advice letter to the brief to counsel, marks every item rule 9, privilege or statute protects, and shows where each one goes when the document is pasted into ChatGPT or Claude. Each page ends with the same document on Ermos, inside the firm.

The documents, one at a time

LetterThe letter of advice

Client, facts, opponent, prospects and strategy. Privileged advice, in the document privilege was made for.

See what leaves →
NotesThe file note of a client conference

Instructions, admissions, health and family details and the solicitor’s own impressions. Nobody outside the room was meant to see this.

See what leaves →
EmailThe client update email

The other side’s position, counsel’s view, the costs so far and the next move, in the most routine email the firm sends.

See what leaves →
EmailThe without-prejudice settlement email

The offer, the reasoning, the pressure points and the walk-away figure. The firm’s negotiating hand, mid-negotiation.

See what leaves →
EmailThe letter to the other side

Everyone named, the client’s position stated, documents demanded. Open correspondence, drafted from a privileged file.

See what leaves →
Report or memoDocuments obtained on discovery

The other side’s documents, produced under compulsion, which the court allows to be used for one purpose only.

See what leaves →
RecordThe family law affidavit

Parties, children, a school, a workplace and the allegations. Everything Part XIVB of the Family Law Act lists as identifying material.

See what leaves →
EmailThe conveyancing settlement email

Purchase price, bank details, identity documents and the settlement date. Everything a payment redirection fraud needs, in one email.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe contract review memo

Counterparties, price, indemnities and the client’s fallback positions, on a deal that is itself under NDA.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe brief to counsel

The chronology, the evidence, the weaknesses and the questions for advice. The whole matter, in the document that goes to the barrister.

See what leaves →
LetterThe letter of demand

The debtor, a director’s personal guarantee, the invoices and an internal note on what the client will accept.

See what leaves →
FormThe will instruction sheet

Children, guardians, a capacity note, assets and a claim not yet decided. A client’s plans for the worst case, in her own words.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe probate inventory spreadsheet

Property, accounts, shares and super, with a column of internal notes about a daughter who may contest. An estate on one sheet.

See what leaves →
LetterThe termination advice letter

A named worker, an allegation, a compensation claim, a union delegate and the amount the client will pay to end it.

See what leaves →
LetterThe letter of instruction to an expert

The questions put to the expert, a gap in the client’s own inspection records and documents produced on subpoena.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe costs agreement and disclosure

The client, her budget, the sister who is paying and the firm’s rates, in the document every matter starts with.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe time and billing spreadsheet

Matters, fee earners, narrations, write-down notes, a deal under NDA and the identity checks, in one month-end export.

See what leaves →
TranscriptThe client call transcript

Medication, a job interview, the settlement floor, the solicitor’s candid view and a deleted text message, in a client’s own words.

See what leaves →
RecordThe draft statement of claim

The parties, the contract, three invoices, a personal guarantee and the solicitor’s note on what not to plead.

See what leaves →
RecordThe draft witness statement

A named witness, a child in hospital, his own eyesight, a supervisor’s conduct and the solicitor’s note on his exact words.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe privilege log spreadsheet

Authors, recipients, descriptions that give the advice away, counsel’s percentage and a waiver note, in one working list.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe deed of settlement and release

The sum, two instalments, a director’s guarantee, a withdrawn cross-claim and a clause promising silence.

See what leaves →
EmailThe directions and timetable email

Pleadings dates, expert timing, witness availability, a hearing estimate and a note on why the client wants speed.

See what leaves →
FormThe family law Financial Statement

Earnings, a home and a mortgage, superannuation, a sister’s payments, a health expense and a claim that has not been decided.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe property pool spreadsheet

Both parties’ figures, who put in what, a transfer to his mother and the split the client will accept.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe medical evidence summary

Diagnoses, prior conditions, a psychiatric history, her husband’s illness, subpoenaed records and the firm’s view on the threshold.

See what leaves →
TranscriptThe conference with counsel

Counsel’s percentages, the client’s bank deadline, a witness who will be hurt and the lowest figure the client will take.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe legal research memo

The client’s facts, discovered documents, the firm’s view, and a High Court case that the memo gets the wrong way round.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe due diligence register

The target, its contracts, its staff, a tax debt and a column of privileged notes on what the client will pay. A deal on one sheet.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe shareholders agreement markup

Ownership, an exit valuation, a lock-out, a possible oppression application and the number the client will take to leave.

See what leaves →
RecordThe client board minutes

A declared interest, a tender under NDA, a settlement authority, an acquisition price and an executive bonus, in one client’s minutes.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe commercial lease review memo

Rent and reviews, options, a make-good estimate, personal guarantees and the reason the client is moving. A lease in one page of advice.

See what leaves →
FormThe AML/CTF customer identification record

Two clients, their passport and licence numbers, where the money came from and the firm’s risk rating. The check every property client now goes through.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe executive employment contract

Pay, a confidential bonus tied to an unannounced acquisition, restraints that name customers and the firm’s own drafting note.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe workplace investigation report

A complainant on sick leave, a respondent with a family loss, a witness who asked not to be named and the findings that decide a career.

See what leaves →
NotesThe conflict check memo

Three people who want the firm to act against its own clients, what they told it on a first call and why the partner said no.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe client trust ledger

Four matters, a deposit from a client’s sister, a $362,118.40 settlement receipt and one ledger that has gone into the red.

See what leaves →
LetterThe response to a Legal Services Commissioner complaint

A complaint from a client’s sister, the limits on what the firm may tell the regulator, the bill, the trust transfer and a candid internal note.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe sale of business agreement

A price split into goodwill, plant and stock, three named staff, a restraint and the ceiling the buyer asked us never to mention.

See what leaves →
LetterThe vendor’s disclosure letter

A change of control right, a tax debt, a threatened commission claim and a worker’s injury, and the buyer’s note on what to refuse.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe deed of assignment of lease

The rent, a bank guarantee, a personal guarantee the client will limit, an option the landlord calls personal and a statement about retail leases.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe data processing agreement

Tenants’ ID documents, servers in three countries, a 24 hour breach notice, a deletion promise and the liability cap the client will accept.

See what leaves →
NotesThe data breach assessment note

A phished mailbox, 212 tenancy applications with ID and bank statements, a 30 day clock and a client who wants to say there is no evidence of misuse.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe franchise agreement review memo

A franchise fee, a pushy signing deadline, a 14 day rule, a termination clause that does not fit the Code and the couple’s loss limit.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe cap table with convertible notes

Founders, angels, two noteholders, a lead investor, a valuation cap, and a note saying how low the founder will go.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe software development agreement

A fixed fee in five milestones, a delivery date driven by an unannounced contract, who owns the code and a developer with six staff.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe IP assignment deed

A contractor with no contract, the code at the heart of the product, a payment dispute, an investor deadline and a second author who signed nothing.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe deed of variation to a fit-out subcontract

Two variations, a 35 day extension, a release, retention figures and the note saying how much the client will pay and what it must not reveal.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe independent contractor agreement

A named contractor, a company roster, company equipment, exclusivity and the firm’s note that he looks like an employee.

See what leaves →
LetterThe show cause and warning letter

Seven late openings, a $340 shortfall, a mother in hospital and a note that the owner wants her gone before Christmas.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe online shop terms and conditions

A fulfilment partner, a returns policy, an excluded-guarantees clause that would be void and a note about an unhappy customer.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe unfair contract terms review memo

The contract terms, 205 customers with fewer than 100 employees, a rating for each clause and a customer’s complaint to the ACCC.

See what leaves →
LetterThe trade mark cease and desist letter

A cafe in Wollongong, a registered mark, a pending application, a threat to sue and a warning not to write to the landlord.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe shareholder loan agreement

A $250,000 advance from savings, the interest, a general security agreement, a bank ranking ahead and a secret job offer.

See what leaves →
RecordThe special resolution to amend a constitution

A neighbourhood garden group, a member recovering from surgery, an objector’s allegation and one resolution that fell short of three-quarters.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe influencer campaign agreement

A named influencer and her agent, a fee, an unannounced launch, rival brands she cannot promote and the owner’s request to bury the #ad.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe deed of guarantee and indemnity

Two directors, their home addresses, a cap and fall-away, a bank guarantee and a note on how much equity one of them holds.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe trade mark portfolio register

Ten marks, three renewals due within a year, one that lapsed, a cafe filing that shows the client’s next move and the agent’s notes.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe casual employment contract

A named new starter, a weekend roster, a 25% loading and the firm’s note on whether she is really casual.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe executive director service agreement

A named executive, a pay package, a restraint, a payment on exit and a note about the chair’s doubts.

See what leaves →
LetterThe redundancy consultation letter

A named accounts officer, a new system, 16 weeks of redundancy pay and a note about the ten year milestone.

See what leaves →
FormThe workplace surveillance notice

Logged websites, 24 hour cameras, GPS in six utes and a note naming the crew member the owner suspects.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe privacy policy review memo

A turnover figure, an overseas email platform, a missing complaints paragraph and a staff habit the client has not disclosed.

See what leaves →
LetterThe access request response letter

Fourteen orders, an allergic reaction, a withheld incident log and a settlement ceiling the customer must not see.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe customer data sharing agreement

Two named businesses, 4,820 and 5,450 customers, an American email platform and a note about 1,900 addresses with no consent.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe refund policy review memo

A no refunds policy, a 20% restocking fee, a stove that failed after five weeks and a $100 million maximum penalty.

See what leaves →
FormThe product recall notification

A lantern battery that overheats, 1,224 buyers, a burn treated by a GP and a note naming the customer and the importer’s tactics.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe subscription and auto-renewal terms

Monthly and annual prices, a free trial that converts, a one-sided price change clause and a churn figure the owner wants to cut.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe business partner exit deed

A 35% shareholding bought out in instalments, a client handover with alarm codes, a bank guarantee and a note on the most the client will pay.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe partnership agreement

Three partners, a 40, 35 and 25 split, a goodwill formula with the arithmetic and a note on one partner’s health.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe share sale agreement

A $2.45 million price with a deposit and a retention, a warranty cap, a named manager, a key customer and a deadline the sellers asked us to hide.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe convertible note deed

A $250,000 note with an 8% coupon, a 20% discount, a $6 million cap, an accountant’s certificate and the cap the founders will really accept.

See what leaves →
EmailThe co-owner dispute email

A lock change, a $41,000 transfer to a rival company, a text threat, a medical certificate and the client’s reading of section 232.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe earn-out calculation spreadsheet

Three years of EBITDA, a $48,000 add-back the buyer refuses, four payment tiers, a set-off claim and a settlement floor.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe heads of agreement for a business sale

A $1.18 million price at 2.96 times earnings, a head chef on $104,000, a 45 day exclusivity and a ceiling the buyer would not want the sellers to see.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe transition services agreement

Four services, $25,700 a month, a tracking system hosted overseas, 3,100 customers and a payroll file that includes a workers compensation claim.

See what leaves →
RecordThe directors’ circular resolution

A $200,000 share issue to a family trust, a director’s interest in it, a pre-emption waiver and the valuation the board does not want shared.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe security documents review memo

A $1.2 million facility, an all-assets security, an equipment financier that ranks first, a negative pledge and a director’s unlimited guarantee.

See what leaves →
LetterThe landlord’s heads of terms for a shop lease

Rent, rent-free months, a fit-out contribution, a director guarantee, make good and the tenant’s own limits in the forwarding email.

See what leaves →
LetterThe make good advice letter to a tenant

The landlord’s claim, where it is weak, the tenant’s own costing, her ceiling and the plan for mediation.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe licence to occupy a pop-up space

The no exclusive possession clause, a 12 week term, the fee, bank details and a note about the client’s own head lease.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe trades subcontract agreement

A lump sum price, 5% retention, a variations clause, payment terms, safety duties and the note saying what the contractor will really pay.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe head contractor’s progress claim schedule

Six packages, two variations, retention, GST and a notes column with a suspension threat and an unsigned variation.

See what leaves →
TranscriptThe contract negotiation call transcript

The other lawyer’s proposals, the board’s authority, a private exchange the recorder kept running through and a summary emailed to everyone.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe software subscription terms

The uptime promise, the liability cap, a price variation right, one-way termination and a note admitting the product misses its own target.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe AI tool procurement agreement

Inputs and outputs, a no training promise, data location, audit rights, an accuracy disclaimer and the note on what the client will trade.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe grant funding agreement review memo

Eight instalments, an audited acquittal, clawback with interest, participant names in every report, seven year audit rights and the charity’s thin reserves.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe draft modern slavery statement and covering notes

Supplier counts, a coded factory with held passports, audit claims, a thin effectiveness section and the note on what the company cannot say.

See what leaves →
LetterThe subpoena response letter

A former client, the six categories of documents sought, a privilege objection, her bank records and an internal note about a family loan.

See what leaves →
FormThe AML/CTF suspicious matter decision record

A buyer, a deposit from an overseas company, a call note that may be privileged, the reporting clock and the plan to stop acting.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe costs estimate tracker spreadsheet

Nine matters, the estimate each client was given, how far fees have run past it, and notes on who has not been told.

See what leaves →
FormThe statutory demand

A client, the company it is chasing, two invoices, an affidavit and a note about the invoice the firm left out.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe memorandum of rent review

A tenant, a landlord, a valuer, a lower rent, a no-decrease clause and a note about a sale the landlord does not know of.

See what leaves →
Statement or scheduleThe itemised bill and trust statement

Narrations that give the advice and the settlement figure, counsel, trust money, GST and the account the client is asked to pay into.

See what leaves →
AgreementThe non-disclosure agreement

Two companies, a deal nobody has announced, named staff, a clause about AI tools and a note on a different NDA.

See what leaves →
SpreadsheetThe case chronology

A court number, a sentence of privileged advice, a witness’s sick child, a surveyor’s report from a subpoena and an expert’s first view.

See what leaves →
Report or memoThe written submissions

A company about to be wound up, a plasterboard dispute, a set-off, an admission in an email and an authority taken from a chatbot.

See what leaves →

How the leakage happens

The mechanism is the same for every document. The whole text is transmitted to the provider’s servers. On personal plans the user cannot choose where it is stored or processed, and for the major providers that has generally meant outside Australia. On consumer tiers it can be retained and used to train future models. The provider’s staff and systems can reach it under the provider’s own policies. Once sent, the firm no longer controls it. Our on-premise vs cloud comparison sets out the four ways to run AI and where each one puts your documents.

The obligations in play

Each marked item on these pages links to the guide that covers its obligation:

The same documents on Ermos

Ermos Dominion drafts and searches on a unit in your office, so the documents never leave it. Ermos Edge keeps your documents on your own instance in an Australian data centre and sends only permitted excerpts, per question, to a named Australian provider. Every page in this series ends with both, item by item.

Common questions

Can lawyers use ChatGPT or Claude with client information?
Not safely in a publicly available tool, as the Law Society's guidance warns. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) recommends in its guidance on commercially available AI products that organisations do not enter personal information, and particularly sensitive information, into publicly available generative AI tools, because of the significant and complex privacy risks. Rule 9 protects confidential client information, and privilege depends on advice staying confidential. Discovered documents may be used only in the proceeding, as Hearne v Street restates. Part XIVB of the Family Law Act restricts communicating to the public an account of family proceedings that identifies a party, witness or child, and whether pasting into an AI tool counts is undecided.
Do ChatGPT and Claude train on what staff paste in?
As at October 2026, whether a conversation on a personal plan (ChatGPT Free, Plus or Pro; Claude Free, Pro or Max) can be used to train the models depends on a setting each user controls. Business plans (ChatGPT Business and Enterprise, Claude Team and Enterprise) and the developer APIs sit under commercial terms, and OpenAI and Anthropic each say they do not train on that content by default (OpenAI, Anthropic). On either product, the thumbs up and thumbs down buttons can send a whole conversation back for training. For lawyers, that matters because privileged advice pasted into a personal account could be used for training without the practice knowing.
Do business plans such as ChatGPT Business or Claude Team solve the problem for lawyers?
Only in part, because the practice would still be relying on an outside company's terms. On a personal plan the user cannot choose where conversations are stored or processed. Some business plans let an organisation choose to store data at rest in Australia (OpenAI), which still leaves the content with the AI company. The OAIC's guidance also tells organisations to review carefully the terms and settings that will apply to their use of any AI product. For lawyers, the careful question then is whether sending privileged advice to a third-party service is consistent with keeping it confidential. Our comparisons with ChatGPT Enterprise and Claude weigh the trade-offs.
What is a safer way for a law firm to use AI with client documents?
A safer way is to draft inside an environment the practice controls. Ermos is built so the document stays under your control. On the Dominion AI unit it is drafted inside your office and none of it is sent to an AI provider. On Ermos Edge your documents and index stay on your own instance in an Australian data centre, and only the question and the excerpts the user is permitted to see go to a named Australian provider that is contractually barred from keeping them or training any model on them. That covers privileged advice, settlement figures and discovered documents alike.
What is AI data leakage in a law firm?
Client information leaving the firm's control through an AI tool. When a document is pasted into ChatGPT or Claude it is transmitted to the provider's servers, can be retained on the provider's terms, can be used to train future models on consumer tiers, and can be reached by the provider's staff and systems. For a law firm the leaked information is usually confidential, often privileged, and sometimes restricted by statute.
Which legal documents carry the most risk?
Anything privileged, anything obtained by compulsory court process, anything from family law proceedings, and anything carrying bank details for settlement. The pages in this series take each one in turn.
Does an enterprise AI subscription change this?
It improves the contract: no training on your data by default, admin controls, shorter retention. The document is still transmitted to and processed by a third party, for the major providers outside Australia, which is the fact a privilege or confidentiality analysis has to deal with. The Law Society guidance expects a careful review of the terms before any client information is involved.

See Dominion answering from your own documents.

A demonstration takes 30 minutes, uses no client data, and comes with no obligation.

Book a demo