Law Firm Refund Policy Review Memos: Use case and AI Confidentiality
Advice on a refund policy is mostly consumer law that anyone could look up, so staff paste the memo into ChatGPT or Claude to tidy the structure and check the section numbers. The memo also carries the client’s real policy wording, its turnover, the profit it made while the policy was live and, in the firm’s note, the name of a customer who was wrongly refused a refund and complained in public. This page marks every item in a memo to an outdoor gear retailer that rule 9 and privilege bear on, separates the public law from the client facts, and shows how the same memo is prepared on Ermos inside the firm.
The refund policy review memo
Prepared when an online retailer asks whether its refund and returns policy is lawful, usually after a complaint or before a relaunch, and signed off by the partner.
Carrick Doyle Lawyers
Privileged and confidential · Memorandum · 10 November 2026
To Eleanor Vance · From Hamish Reid · Client: Eldridge Outdoor Supply Pty Ltd
1. Instructions. Bianca Eldridge, owner of Eldridge Outdoor Supply Pty Ltd (ABN 51 824 753 556), which sells camping and hiking gear online from a warehouse in Wetherill Park, asked on 3 November for a review of the shop’s refund policy. Turnover last year was $3.1 million.1
2. What the policy says. “All sales are final. No refunds or exchanges on sale items.” This appears on the policy page and on every order confirmation since 1 March 2026.2
“Unused items in original packaging may be returned within 14 days for store credit. The customer pays return postage and a 20% restocking fee applies.”3
“Faulty items are repaired under the manufacturer’s 12 month warranty. After 12 months we cannot help.”4
3. The problem. The first and third statements tell consumers they have fewer rights than the Australian Consumer Law gives them. A contract term is void to the extent that it excludes, restricts or modifies the consumer guarantees (s 64), and a false or misleading representation about the existence, exclusion or effect of a guarantee, right or remedy contravenes s 29(1)(m). The ACCC says it is illegal to rely on store policies that deny these rights, such as “no refunds”. The second statement is acceptable for change of mind, which the Act does not require a business to refund, if the shop follows it and does not apply it to faulty goods.5
4. What a customer can demand. If goods fail a guarantee such as acceptable quality (s 54) and the failure is major, the consumer can reject the goods and choose a refund or replacement, or keep them and claim compensation for the drop in value (s 259(3)). A failure is major if, for example, a reasonable consumer fully acquainted with it would not have bought the goods, or the goods are unsafe (s 260(1)). If it is not major the shop may choose to repair, replace or refund (ss 259(2) and 261). A restocking fee cannot reduce what a consumer gets back for a faulty item (s 64), and for goods too large or heavy to return without significant cost the shop must collect them at its own expense within a reasonable time (s 263(2) and (3)).6
The guarantees are not limited to a manufacturer’s warranty period. How long goods must last depends on the type of goods, their price and how they are used, and the ACCC gives the example of a $1,800 fridge that stopped working after four and a half years, where there is a good argument the guarantee was not met. A $390 tent that fails after 14 months may well be a failure.7
5. Penalties. Section 29 is in Part 3-1, so for conduct on or after 28 March 2026 the maximum penalty for a company is the greater of $100 million and, if the benefit can be worked out, three times that benefit or otherwise 30% of adjusted turnover (s 224(3) and (3A), as amended by Act No. 19 of 2026), and $2.5 million for an individual. Earlier conduct is subject to the lower maximum then in force.8
6. Proposed wording. “Our goods come with guarantees under the Australian Consumer Law that cannot be excluded. For a major problem you can choose a refund or replacement. For a minor problem we will repair, replace or refund. If you simply change your mind we will accept unused items within 14 days for store credit; you pay return postage.”9
[Internal, delete before sending] Bianca refused Sunil Grantham a refund on 29 September for a stove that stopped igniting after five weeks, and he complained on a camping forum on 14 October. That is a failure the Act covers, so he is owed a repair, replacement or refund. She wants to rewrite the policy and say nothing about the past. Refund Sunil first. Her profit on sale items since March is about $31,000, which is the kind of benefit a court looks at under s 224(3A)(b). The policy ran from 1 March, so conduct before 28 March sits under the lower maximum and conduct after it under the higher one. Do not let her rely on a terms of trade disclaimer.10
An invented memo, shown with the firm’s note still attached. The ABN is the ATO’s published example. Hover or tap any highlighted item for the analysis; the full list is below.
Refund policy review drafter
An Agent+ that prepares the first draft of a refund policy review memo. It reads the retailer's policy, the complaint on file and the checklist and guidance extracts your firm keeps, then sets out each clause beside the matching extract in your memo format, with questions for the partner marked.
What it does
- Reads the policy, the complaint and the retailer's instructions
- Sets each clause against your checklist and guidance extracts
- Drafts the memo in your format with open questions
What stays with your people. The partner forms the view on whether the policy is lawful and settles the memo. The agent compares and drafts; it gives no opinion.
An Agent+ is built once and anyone in the practice can run it. It works from your own documents and runs on Ermos Dominion, the AI unit in your office, or on Ermos Edge, your own instance in an Australian data centre.
What leaves the firm
- 1The client, its ABN, location and turnover
A named business, its ABN, a suburb and an annual turnover. The ABN is on a public register, but the turnover and the instruction are the client’s confidential information under rule 9. Rule 9 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The client’s turnover and instruction transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 2The “all sales are final” wording
The client’s live policy text and how long it has been on every order confirmation. The wording is public, but the date it went live and its reach matter to penalties, and the firm’s analysis of it is privileged. Rule 9 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The client’s live policy wording and its start date transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 3The store credit, postage and restocking terms
The client’s change of mind terms. The ACCC says a business need not refund a change of mind, but must follow its own change of mind policy if it has one.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Terms the client already publishes; moderate value alone Ermos Edge The AI can restate the change of mind rule; a lawyer must check it against the ACCC guidance Ermos Dominion The AI can restate the change of mind rule; a lawyer must check it against the ACCC guidance Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 4The 12 month warranty statement
The client’s statement limiting help to a manufacturer’s warranty. It is the kind of statement s 64 and s 29(1)(m) bear on, because the guarantees apply apart from any warranty. Rule 9 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The client’s wording and the firm’s view of it transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 5The legal analysis of the first and third statements
A statement of the law applied to the client’s wording. Section 64 voids a term to the extent it excludes, restricts or modifies the guarantees, and s 29(1)(m) prohibits a false or misleading representation about the existence, exclusion or effect of a guarantee, right or remedy. Most of the paragraph is public law, and the application to the client is the firm’s advice. Legal privilege guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Mostly public law applied to wording the client publishes Ermos Edge Leaves only inside a permitted excerpt; whether a statement is misleading is for a lawyer Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit; whether a statement is misleading is for a lawyer Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 6The remedies analysis
A statement of the consumer remedies. A consumer can reject goods for a major failure and choose a refund or replacement (s 259(3)); for a failure that is not major the supplier may choose to repair, replace or refund (ss 259(2) and 261); and for goods that cannot be returned without significant cost the supplier collects them at its own expense (s 263(3)). No client fact in it.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) A statement of public law with no client fact; the risk is an AI misstating a section Ermos Edge The AI can restate the remedies but can misstate a section, so a lawyer must verify it Ermos Dominion The AI can restate the remedies but can misstate a section, so a lawyer must verify it Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 7The warranty period and the tent example
The firm’s view that a guarantee is not fixed at 12 months, with an invented product and price used to illustrate. The ACCC says how long goods must last depends on the nature of the goods, their cost and their use, and gives the example of a fridge failing after four and a half years where there is a good argument the guarantee was not met. Legal privilege guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Public guidance and an invented example; the risk is an AI treating one example as a rule Ermos Edge The AI can restate the guidance but a lawyer must judge how long a particular product should last Ermos Dominion The AI can restate the guidance but a lawyer must judge how long a particular product should last Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 8The maximum penalties
A statement of the law. Section 224 sets the maximum for contraventions of Part 3-1, which includes s 29. The higher amounts apply to acts or omissions on or after 28 March 2026 (Act No. 19 of 2026 and ACL s 310). No client fact in it.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) A statement of public law with no client fact; the risk is an AI misstating a commencement date Ermos Edge The AI can restate the penalty but can misstate a commencement date, so a lawyer must verify it Ermos Dominion The AI can restate the penalty but can misstate a commencement date, so a lawyer must verify it Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 9The proposed policy wording
Plain statements of the consumer guarantees and a change of mind policy. Nothing in it is client-specific, and the client will publish it.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Standard consumer law wording the client will publish, but sent before the client has approved it Ermos Edge The AI can draft the wording but a lawyer must check it against the Act Ermos Dominion The AI can draft the wording but a lawyer must check it against the Act Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case - 10The firm’s note on a named customer, the benefit and the owner’s wish to say nothing
Privileged advice, a named customer who was refused and complained publicly, the owner’s profit figure and an instruction about how to treat the past. The customer is not the firm’s client and has no relationship with the AI provider. A note written to be deleted before sending is the line that goes missing when the memo is pasted. Legal privilege guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Privileged advice, a named complainant and the client’s profit now on a third party’s servers; on consumer tiers it can train future models Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Refund policy review drafter. Drafts the review memo by setting a retailer's refund and returns policy against the checklist and guidance extracts your firm supplies, with open questions listed for the partner. See the use case
What happens in Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude)
- The whole document is transmitted to the provider’s servers. On personal plans the user cannot choose where it is stored or processed, and for the major providers that has generally meant outside Australia, under that country’s legal process. Some business plans offer storage in Australia, but the provider still receives the content.
- On consumer tiers, prompts can be retained and used to train future models.
- The provider’s staff and systems can reach the content under the provider’s own policies.
- Once sent, the firm no longer controls it. Retention and deletion happen on the provider’s terms.
The same document on Ermos
Ermos Dominion
The document is drafted on a unit in your office, from your own templates and the matter file. Every marked item stays on the unit, which keeps working with the internet switched off. Nothing in it is transmitted to an AI provider, so there is no disclosure to analyse: the confidentiality work is the same as for your file server.
Ermos Edge
Your documents, the index and your access boundaries stay on your own instance in an Australian data centre. When a staff member asks for this draft, only their question and the excerpts they are permitted to see go to a named Australian provider, who is contractually barred from keeping the content or training any model on it. Nothing is processed outside Australia.
| Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) | Ermos Edge | Ermos Dominion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the document is processed | Provider servers, generally offshore on personal plans | Your instance in an Australian data centre; answers generated in Australia | The unit in your office |
| Who can read it | Provider staff and systems, under policy | Your staff, within the boundaries you set. The named Australian provider processes only permitted excerpts, under contract, and keeps nothing | Your staff only |
| Is it kept | On the provider’s terms | Kept on your instance; the provider is barred from retaining it | Stays on the unit |
| Can it train a model | On consumer tiers, yes | No, by contract | Only your own unit learns from it, on your hardware |
Part of Use cases in law firms. See how this works in practice: Consumer law advice on Ermos.
Common questions
Do ChatGPT and Claude use the information in a refund policy review memo?
Is it safe to paste a refund policy review memo into ChatGPT or Claude?
Can ChatGPT or Claude be trusted to draft a refund policy review memo?
How can a law firm use AI for a refund policy review memo without sending it to ChatGPT or Claude?
Can a shop put up a no refunds sign?
What can a customer demand when goods are faulty?
What is the maximum penalty for misleading customers about refunds?
See Dominion answering from your own documents.
A demonstration takes 30 minutes, uses no client data, and comes with no obligation.
Book a demo