Use cases and AI confidentiality in mortgage broking: what leaves when client files go into ChatGPT or Claude.
A mortgage broker holds the documents a household would least like to see leave: payslips, bank statements, identity documents, credit reports and the reasons one loan was recommended over another. The National Consumer Credit Protection Act requires a broker to act in the consumer’s best interests (sections 158LA and 158LE), to give the consumer’s interests priority where they conflict with the broker’s, and to make reasonable inquiries and take reasonable steps to verify the consumer’s financial situation (section 117). The Privacy Act treats everything in the file as personal information, subject to its small business exemption. This series takes 23 documents a brokerage produces, marks every protected item, and shows where each one goes when the document is pasted into ChatGPT or Claude. Each page ends with the same document on Ermos.
The documents, one at a time
Two identities, employers, every account and card, the children, the property and a family gift. A household on one form.
See what leaves → SpreadsheetThe serviceability spreadsheetNet income, shaded overtime, living expenses, every card limit and a surplus of a few hundred dollars. How close a family is to its limit.
See what leaves → NotesThe best interests file noteThe clients’ objectives, the lenders compared, the commission difference and the broker’s candid impressions. Why this loan, in writing.
See what leaves → EmailThe lender submission emailThe applicants, the deal, income, a family gift, a late payment, an earlier decline and the broker’s candid aside. The pitch, before the lender sees it.
See what leaves → RecordThe supporting documents summaryIdentity scans, payslips, bank statements, a credit report and what the family spends money on. The paperwork a household would least like read by a stranger.
See what leaves → EmailThe pre-approval email to clientsThe lender, the amount, the conditions, the savings advice and a private plan mentioned on a call. Good news, with the clients’ whole position in it.
See what leaves → EmailThe declined application emailThe decline reason, the credit enquiry, an admitted error and the plan B. The worst day of the application, in writing.
See what leaves → TranscriptThe broker and client call transcriptIncome, a job worry, a late payment, a family gift, a private plan and the broker’s advice, in the clients’ own words.
See what leaves → SpreadsheetThe commission and clawback spreadsheetEvery client with a loan amount and lender, the commission rates, trail income and the date each clawback ends. The brokerage’s book of business.
See what leaves → LetterThe complaint responseThe allegation, the chronology, a quote from the call recording, a partial admission and the remedy, in a letter AFCA may read next.
See what leaves → SpreadsheetThe refinance comparison spreadsheetThe current loan, a private retention offer, four rates, a cashback, what the brokerage earns on each and the five-year cost. The case for switching, in one grid.
See what leaves → LetterThe hardship notice letterA cancer diagnosis, a redundancy, a household budget with a shortfall and the savings that cover it. The worst month of a family’s year, addressed to the lender.
See what leaves → FormThe self-employed income verification checklistTwo years of tax returns, a tax file number on a scan, add-backs, a payment plan with the ATO and an accountant’s letter. A sole trader’s whole financial life.
See what leaves → Report or memoThe data breach assessment noteA pack of licences, payslips and credit reports sent to the wrong client, the employee who sent it and the director’s reasoning for not telling the regulator.
See what leaves → Statement or scheduleThe credit proposal disclosure documentThe loan, the commission the lender pays, the broker’s own bonus, the lender’s fees and the lender that declined. What the deal is worth to everyone, on one page.
See what leaves → RecordThe preliminary assessment recordGoals, income, debts, credit scores, real spending against declared spending, a thin surplus and a plan for a third child. The whole case for the loan, and the doubts.
See what leaves → SpreadsheetThe loan pipeline trackerNine client files on one sheet, with the complaint, the tax debt, the separation, the surgery and the commission forecast in the notes. The whole brokerage in twelve rows.
See what leaves → FormThe privacy consent and credit reporting authorityIdentity documents, a surgery, an old default, the lenders in view and a promise about overseas disclosure. The form that says where client information may go.
See what leaves → FormThe first home buyer scheme eligibility checklistCitizenship, a visa, a Medicare number, a flat once owned in Denmark, the savings and a possible move to Perth. Everything a scheme asks a first home buyer to prove.
See what leaves → SpreadsheetThe construction loan progress payment scheduleThe clients, their land, the builder’s fixed price and bank details, every stage claim and the interest as the loan grows. A build, to the dollar.
See what leaves → EmailThe annual client review emailThe loan and its rates, a new job on probation, parental leave, a renovation plan and how the brokerage is paid. A year of a family’s changes in one email.
See what leaves → SpreadsheetThe lender policy comparisonOne client against four lenders: his employer and bonus, an expected rent, his debts, each lender’s policy and commission, and a lender manager’s remark that is not in writing.
See what leaves → RecordThe employment verification recordA client’s written limits, his pay, a surgery the employer mentioned unasked, the employer’s lost client, a job in Perth and what was left out of the email to the lender.
See what leaves →How the leakage happens
The mechanism is the same for every document. The whole text is transmitted to the provider’s servers. On personal plans the user cannot choose where it is stored or processed, and for the major providers that has generally meant outside Australia. On consumer tiers it can be retained and used to train future models. The provider’s staff and systems can reach it under the provider’s own policies. Once sent, the brokerage no longer controls it. Our on-premise vs cloud comparison sets out the four ways to run AI and where each one puts your documents.
The obligations in play
Each marked item on these pages links to the guide that covers its obligation:
- The Privacy Act, the APPs and AI
- APP 8 cross-border disclosure and AI
- Choosing an on-premise or private cloud AI provider
The same documents on Ermos
Ermos Dominion drafts and searches on a unit in your office, so the documents never leave it. Ermos Edge keeps your documents on your own instance in an Australian data centre and sends only permitted excerpts, per question, to a named Australian provider. Every page in this series ends with both, item by item.
Common questions
Can mortgage brokers use ChatGPT or Claude with client information?
Do ChatGPT and Claude train on what staff paste in?
Do business plans such as ChatGPT Business or Claude Team solve the problem for mortgage brokers?
What is the safest way for a mortgage brokerage to use AI with client documents?
What is AI data leakage in a mortgage brokerage?
Which broking documents carry the most risk?
Do the credit laws say anything about AI?
See Dominion answering from your own documents.
A demonstration takes 30 minutes, uses no client data, and comes with no obligation.
Book a demo