Accountant Failure to Lodge Penalty Remission Letters: Use case and AI Confidentiality
When a client lodges late, the registered tax agent writes to the ATO to ask for the failure to lodge penalty to be remitted and explains why the returns were late. Staff paste the draft into ChatGPT or Claude to make the story read better. The letter names the client, says what went wrong in the business, and often describes a director’s hospital stay, the practice’s own part in the delay and the client’s other debts. This page marks every item in a realistic draft, shows where a smoothed-over sentence can say something the facts do not support, and shows how the same letter is drafted on Ermos inside the practice.
The failure to lodge penalty remission letter
Drafted once the returns are ready to lodge and held until they have been. The ATO says it expects outstanding documents to be lodged before a remission request, and that it has the power to remit all or part of a failure to lodge penalty on the client’s circumstances. Section 298-20(1) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 says the Commissioner may remit all or a part of a penalty.
Northgate Partners
Chartered Accountants · DRAFT for approval, Friday 20 November 2026
To: Australian Taxation Office, by Online services for agents
Re: Harbourline Joinery Pty Ltd, ABN 51 824 753 556. Request to remit failure to lodge penalties. ATO reference 0000 0000 44171
We act for Harbourline Joinery Pty Ltd and ask the Commissioner to remit the failure to lodge penalties on its 2025 and 2026 income tax returns, under section 298-20 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 19538.
Lodgment. Both returns were lodged on Friday 27 November 2026.2
What happened. Harbourline lost its largest customer in July when Coastline Developments went into administration owing it $96,000. Revenue for the September quarter was 22% below the prior year, and the company cut its staff from six to three.3 Mr Daniel Okafor, who runs the business and signs its returns, was in hospital for four days in September with a heart condition.4
Why the returns were late. These events meant the company could not lodge either return on time.5
Time. We did not ask the ATO for more time before 31 October. That was our responsibility as the company’s agent and we should have rung on 28 October.6
Compliance and payment. The September quarter activity statement was lodged on Wednesday 18 November and a payment arrangement starts on Friday 27 November. On the officer’s estimate of 4 November the penalties could be up to $3,640 for each return, which the ATO has not yet confirmed in writing.7
The request. We ask that the penalties be remitted in full. If the Commissioner remits only part, or refuses, we ask for written notice of the decision and the reasons for it8.
Attached: Mr Okafor’s hospital discharge summary (two pages) and the administrators’ notice for Coastline Developments.9
Yours faithfully,
Tom Nakamura, Registered Tax Agent 2345 6789, Northgate Partners10
Review note (not for sending). Sarah: the 2025 return was overdue before September, so the hospital stay cannot explain it. Reword before Daniel sees it. Daniel has not approved the wording yet.
An invented draft. The ABN is the ATO’s published example value; the ATO reference is a placeholder. Hover or tap any highlighted item for the analysis; the full list is below.
Penalty remission letter drafter
An Agent+ that prepares a draft remission letter from the client file: the circumstances recorded, the returns outstanding and the dates involved. It writes in your house style from your own letter templates, and sets out what the file does not yet show.
What it does
- Reads the client file and the circumstances recorded
- Drafts the letter from your own remission template
- Flags missing facts, documents and unfinished returns
What stays with your people. A tax agent or partner reads, settles and decides whether the letter goes. The agent drafts; it does not send.
An Agent+ is built once and anyone in the practice can run it. It works from your own documents and runs on Ermos Dominion, the AI unit in your office, or on Ermos Edge, your own instance in an Australian data centre.
What leaves the firm
- 1The client, its ABN and the ATO reference
A named client, its ABN and the ATO reference for the call on 4 November. The ABN is public on ABN Lookup, but beside the rest of the letter it ties every item to one company, and the reference identifies the call in the ATO’s own records. Confidential client information under APES 110 (subsection 114, which binds members of CA ANZ, CPA Australia and the Institute of Public Accountants), and information about a client’s affairs that Code item 6 of section 30-10 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 bears on for a registered tax agent or BAS agent. The TPB’s guidance statement TPB(GS) 55/2026 says a registered tax agent or BAS agent needs the client’s permission before client information goes to a third party, which can include entering it into an AI tool, depending on how the tool is configured and used. APES 110 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Client name, ABN and an ATO reference transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 2A lodgment date that has not happened yet
The draft states that both returns were lodged on 27 November, which is the plan and not yet a fact. The ATO says it expects outstanding documents to be lodged before a remission request, and lists a request made before lodging among those it is unlikely to accept. A tool will turn a planned date into a past one. Code item 9 of section 30-10 requires reasonable care in ascertaining a client’s state of affairs where it is relevant to a statement the agent makes on the client’s behalf, so a person has to confirm the date before the letter is dated or sent. Checking AI output guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) A planned date written as a past fact; the tool cannot know which Ermos Edge Not about where data goes: a person has to confirm the lodgment date Ermos Dominion Not about where data goes: a person has to confirm the lodgment date Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 3The collapse of a customer and the client’s trading position
That the client lost its largest customer to an administration, the amount owed, the fall in revenue and the cut in staff. Confidential financial information about the client and a third company’s insolvency. It is also the client’s own account of what went wrong, so the client has to approve it before it goes to the ATO. APES 110 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The client’s trading position and a third party’s insolvency transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 4The director’s hospital stay and heart condition
A named person’s admission and diagnosis. Health information about an individual is sensitive information under the Privacy Act (section 6(1); section 6FA includes information about an individual’s illness), where the Act applies to the practice. The ATO says it reviews each request on its merits and lists the circumstances it would likely accept or decline, including that it is unlikely to accept a short-term illness that is not severe. The letter cannot promise a result, and Mr Okafor should see this sentence before it is sent. Patient data guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) A named person’s hospital stay and diagnosis transmitted Ermos Edge Only the question and permitted excerpts go to a named Australian provider; who may see health information is still set by you Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 5A sentence that says more than the facts support
The draft says the events meant the company could not lodge either return on time. The 2026 return fell due on 31 October, after the hospital stay. The 2025 return was already overdue before September, so the hospital stay cannot explain it. The ATO asks for the specific event, how it caused the delay and whether the penalty was caused by circumstances beyond the client’s control. A tool asked to improve the story will smooth over a gap like this. A statement to the ATO that does not match the facts is the practice’s problem under Code item 9. Checking AI output guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Little client data in the sentence itself, but a tool will smooth over a gap that has to be fixed by a person Ermos Edge Not about where data goes: a person has to check the story against the facts Ermos Dominion Not about where data goes: a person has to check the story against the facts Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 6The practice’s admission that it did not ask for more time
An admission that the agent should have rung the ATO before the due date. The ATO says it asks why the client or the tax professional was not able to request further time. Section 286-75(1A) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 means a client is not liable to the penalty if it engaged a registered tax agent or BAS agent, gave the agent all relevant information, and the agent’s failure did not result from intentional disregard or recklessness. If the practice’s own conduct contributed, its interests may differ from the client’s, which Code items 4 and 5 bear on. Whether to include the sentence is a decision for the partner, and the practice may want to tell its insurer first. TPB Code guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The practice’s admission about its own conduct transmitted Ermos Edge Stays in Australia, but whether to include the admission is still the partner’s call Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit, but whether to include the admission is still the partner’s call Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 7The client’s other lodgments, its payment arrangement and the estimate
That the activity statement is lodged, that a payment arrangement starts on 27 November and an unconfirmed penalty figure. The ATO says it considers general compliance history, outstanding returns and tax debts, and that a good history includes paying non-disputed debt or having a payment plan. The $3,640 is the officer’s estimate on the call, and the call note records that the penalty unit value was not confirmed, so a person has to check it against the ATO’s written calculation. APES 110 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The client’s other lodgments, payment arrangement and a penalty estimate transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 8The legal basis and the right to reasons
Section 298-20(1) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 says the Commissioner may remit all or a part of the penalty. Section 298-20(2) requires written notice of the decision and the reasons if the Commissioner does not remit the penalty or remits only part, and subsection (3) allows an objection if the penalty payable after a refusal is more than 2 penalty units. This is public law with no client data in the wording.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Public law with no client data in the wording Ermos Edge Nothing to protect in public law Ermos Dominion Nothing to protect in public law Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 9The attachments, including a hospital document
A discharge summary is more health information than a remission request needs. The ATO says the client should give enough information for it to decide, such as the event and how it caused the delay. Attaching more than that puts a hospital record, with a diagnosis and clinical detail, in front of an AI tool as well as the ATO. A person should decide the minimum to send. The administrators’ notice is a public document about a third party. Patient data guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) A description of a hospital record transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case - 10The sender
Names the agent and the registration number, which ties the letter to a registered tax agent and makes any leak traceable to the practice. TPB Code guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Transmitted, and the leak is traceable to you Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Penalty remission letter drafter. Drafts the remission request from the circumstances the client has described and your own letter template, and lists the facts and supporting documents still missing. See the use case
What happens in Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude)
- The whole document is transmitted to the provider’s servers. On personal plans the user cannot choose where it is stored or processed, and for the major providers that has generally meant outside Australia, under that country’s legal process. Some business plans offer storage in Australia, but the provider still receives the content.
- On consumer tiers, prompts can be retained and used to train future models.
- The provider’s staff and systems can reach the content under the provider’s own policies.
- Once sent, the firm no longer controls it. Retention and deletion happen on the provider’s terms.
The same document on Ermos
Ermos Dominion
The document is drafted on a unit in your office, from your own templates and the client file. Every marked item stays on the unit, which keeps working with the internet switched off. Nothing in it is transmitted to an AI provider, so there is no disclosure to analyse: the confidentiality work is the same as for your file server.
Ermos Edge
Your documents, the index and your access boundaries stay on your own instance in an Australian data centre. When a staff member asks for this draft, only their question and the excerpts they are permitted to see go to a named Australian provider, who is contractually barred from keeping the content or training any model on it. Nothing is processed outside Australia.
| Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) | Ermos Edge | Ermos Dominion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the document is processed | Provider servers, generally offshore on personal plans | Your instance in an Australian data centre; answers generated in Australia | The unit in your office |
| Who can read it | Provider staff and systems, under policy | Your staff, within the boundaries you set. The named Australian provider processes only permitted excerpts, under contract, and keeps nothing | Your staff only |
| Is it kept | On the provider’s terms | Kept on your instance; the provider is barred from retaining it | Stays on the unit |
| Can it train a model | On consumer tiers, yes | No, by contract | Only your own unit learns from it, on your hardware |
Part of Use cases in accounting firms. See how this works in practice: Client correspondence on Ermos.
Common questions
Do ChatGPT and Claude use the information in a failure to lodge penalty remission letter?
Can we use ChatGPT or Claude for a remission letter to the ATO if we remove the names?
Does deleting the chat remove a remission letter from ChatGPT or Claude?
How can an accounting practice use AI for a failure to lodge penalty remission letter without sending it to ChatGPT or Claude?
Can the ATO remit a failure to lodge penalty?
What happens if the ATO refuses to remit the whole penalty?
Is a client liable for a failure to lodge penalty if its tax agent lodged late?
See Dominion answering from your own documents.
A demonstration takes 30 minutes, uses no client data, and comes with no obligation.
Book a demo