Accountant Director Penalty Notice Advice Letters: Use case and AI Confidentiality
A director penalty notice makes two people personally liable for a company’s tax debt, and the accountant who acts for the company has days to explain it. The letter sets out the amount, the 21 days, the ways the penalty can be remitted and what the directors should do next. Staff paste a draft into ChatGPT or Claude to make it plainer. That sends the company’s debt, its cash position, the directors’ names and the advice itself to an AI company while the directors are still deciding. This page marks every item in a realistic letter and shows how the same letter is drafted on Ermos inside the practice.
The director penalty notice advice letter
Written when the ATO has given the directors of a company a notice of a director penalty for unpaid PAYG withholding, superannuation guarantee charge or GST. Under section 269-25 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 the Commissioner must not begin proceedings until 21 days after giving the notice, and section 269-30 sets out when the penalty is remitted.
Northgate Partners
(02) 5550 0100 · Thursday 12 November 2026
Lena Marchetti and Marco Marchetti, directors, Marchetti Dental Pty Ltd, trading as Northside Smile Studio1
Dear Lena and Marco,
Director penalty notices dated Monday 9 November 2026, ATO reference 0000 0000 33022
The ATO has given each of you a notice of a director penalty for the company. This letter explains what it means and what you need to decide before Monday 30 November.
What the notice says. The unpaid amount is $41,200, the PAYG withholding for the June 2026 quarter, which the company reported in July but did not pay when it was due on 28 July. The notice was posted on 9 November, so the ATO cannot start proceedings until after the end of Monday 30 November.3
Why it is personal. Under Division 269 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 the directors must cause the company to pay, or to go into voluntary administration or liquidation. Each director is liable for a penalty equal to the unpaid amount (section 269-20). If one of you pays, the company’s liability and the other’s are discharged to the same extent (section 269-40), and the one who pays has the rights of a guarantor against the company and the other (section 269-45).4
How the penalty goes away. It is remitted if the directors stop being under the obligation within 21 days of the notice, because the company pays what it owes, an administrator or small business restructuring practitioner is appointed, or the company begins to be wound up (sections 269-15(2) and 269-30(1)). The company reported this PAYG within 3 months of the due date. If it had not, appointing an administrator or winding up after that point would not remit the penalty (section 269-30(2), item 1).5
The payment plan. Our request of 5 November has not been answered. Section 269-15(3) says the Commissioner must not commence or take a procedural step in proceedings while an arrangement covering the company’s obligation is in force under section 255-15. It does not say the penalty is remitted, so an agreed plan that is kept protects you from proceedings but does not cancel the notice. We do not yet know how the ATO will apply the $8,000 due on 20 November, or whether the $1,108 of interest must also be paid to end the obligation. We have asked in writing.6
The money. The operating account held $38,420 on 3 November. Paying $41,200 before the end of 30 November needs about $2,780 more, while wages and the October BAS are also coming up. If you can find it, paying the $41,200 is the step the Act points to for both of you, and we have asked the ATO about the interest.7
Defences. The Act excuses a director who, because of illness or another good reason, could not reasonably have been expected to take part in management and did not take part, and one who took all reasonable steps to see that the company complied, or that it went into administration or restructuring or was wound up, or for whom there were no such steps to take (section 269-35). You have both run the practice every day and I do not see either defence applying, but you should have a solicitor confirm.8
Our role. We act for the company on tax. We are not insolvency practitioners or lawyers. Whether to appoint an administrator or restructuring practitioner is for you to decide with a registered liquidator or a solicitor. Each of you is personally exposed, so you may each want your own advice, and we cannot act for one of you against the other.9
Please call me by Monday 16 November so we can decide whether to bring the $8,000 forward.
Yours sincerely,
Tom Nakamura CPA, Registered Tax Agent 2345 678910
An invented letter. The ATO reference and registration number are placeholders. Hover or tap any highlighted item for the analysis; the full list is below.
Director penalty notice letter drafter
An Agent+ that prepares the first draft of a letter to directors who have received a director penalty notice. It reads the notice, the debt detail and the company file, follows your letter template and sets out the debt and each date shown on the notice.
What it does
- Reads the notice, the debt detail and the company file
- Drafts the letter to each director in your template
- Flags dates and figures the partner should check
What stays with your people. A partner gives the advice, decides what the letter says and sends it. The agent drafts; it does not advise.
An Agent+ is built once and anyone in the practice can run it. It works from your own documents and runs on Ermos Dominion, the AI unit in your office, or on Ermos Edge, your own instance in an Australian data centre.
What leaves the firm
- 1The directors and the company
Two named individuals, their company and its trading name. Information about the clients’ affairs that a registered tax agent may not disclose to a third party without permission (Code item 6, section 30-10 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009), and confidential client information under APES 110 (R114.2). TPB Code guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Transmitted to the provider, generally offshore on personal plans Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 2The notice date and reference
The date the notice was given and the ATO’s reference. Under section 269-25(4) a notice is taken to be given when the Commissioner leaves or posts it, and every deadline in the letter runs from that date, so a person has to check it against the notice. Checking AI output guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The dates are the client’s, and the provider does not check them against the notice Ermos Edge Stays in Australia, but the dates still need checking against the notice Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit, but the dates still need checking against the notice Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 3The amount and the timeline
The unpaid PAYG, the quarter, the due date and the date proceedings can start. A debt owed to the ATO is confidential financial information about the company, and the dates are arithmetic from the notice (21 days after 9 November) that a person must verify. APES 110 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The company’s debt transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 4Why the liability is personal
Division 269 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 and sections 269-20, 269-40 and 269-45. This is public law with no client data in the paragraph.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Public law with no client data in the wording Ermos Edge Nothing to protect in public law Ermos Dominion Nothing to protect in public law Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 5How the penalty is remitted
Sections 269-15(2) and 269-30, including the table in subsection 269-30(2) that stops a late administration or winding up from remitting a PAYG penalty that was not reported within 3 months of the due date. This is public law, but which side of the line the company is on depends on its facts.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Public law, but its application turns on the company’s facts Ermos Edge Stays in Australia, but which side of the 3 month line applies still needs a person Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit, but which side of the 3 month line applies still needs a person Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 6The payment plan and what is still unknown
A request not yet answered, the 21 day clock and two questions the practice has put to the ATO. Section 269-15(3) bars proceedings while an arrangement is in force but does not remit the penalty. The letter records the practice’s uncertainty, which should not be tidied into a confident statement by a tool. Checking AI output guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The practice’s doubts transmitted before the ATO has answered Ermos Edge Stays in Australia, but what the ATO will agree is still unknown Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit, but what the ATO will agree is still unknown Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 7The cash position
The balance of the company’s operating account on a given day and the shortfall against the debt. Confidential financial information that a lender, a supplier or the ATO would value. APES 110 confidentiality guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) The company’s cash position transmitted Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 8The assessment of the defences
A view that neither director has a defence under section 269-35. It is an assessment of two named people’s conduct, it is a judgement a person must make and a solicitor should check, and it should not leave the practice in draft. Checking AI output guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) An assessment of two named directors transmitted Ermos Edge Stays in Australia, but whether a defence applies is still a legal judgement Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit, but whether a defence applies is still a legal judgement Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 9The limits of the practice’s role
A statement that the practice acts for the company on tax, is not an insolvency practitioner or lawyer and cannot act for one director against the other. It advises the clients of their position under the tax law (Code item 12, section 30-10). It is generic wording with no client data. TPB Code guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Generic limits-of-advice wording with no client data Ermos Edge Nothing to protect in generic wording Ermos Dominion Nothing to protect in generic wording Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case - 10The signatory
Ties the letter to a CPA and registered tax agent bound by the Code, and makes any leak traceable to the practice. TPB Code guide.
Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) Transmitted, and the leak is traceable to you Ermos Edge Stays on your instance in Australia; leaves only inside a permitted excerpt, per question, to the named provider Ermos Dominion Stays on the unit in your office Use case Director penalty notice letter drafter. Drafts the letter to the directors from the notice and the file, setting out the debt, the dates and the points the partner wants covered. See the use case
What happens in Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude)
- The whole document is transmitted to the provider’s servers. On personal plans the user cannot choose where it is stored or processed, and for the major providers that has generally meant outside Australia, under that country’s legal process. Some business plans offer storage in Australia, but the provider still receives the content.
- On consumer tiers, prompts can be retained and used to train future models.
- The provider’s staff and systems can reach the content under the provider’s own policies.
- Once sent, the firm no longer controls it. Retention and deletion happen on the provider’s terms.
The same document on Ermos
Ermos Dominion
The document is drafted on a unit in your office, from your own templates and the client file. Every marked item stays on the unit, which keeps working with the internet switched off. Nothing in it is transmitted to an AI provider, so there is no disclosure to analyse: the confidentiality work is the same as for your file server.
Ermos Edge
Your documents, the index and your access boundaries stay on your own instance in an Australian data centre. When a staff member asks for this draft, only their question and the excerpts they are permitted to see go to a named Australian provider, who is contractually barred from keeping the content or training any model on it. Nothing is processed outside Australia.
| Frontier Models (ChatGPT, Claude) | Ermos Edge | Ermos Dominion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the document is processed | Provider servers, generally offshore on personal plans | Your instance in an Australian data centre; answers generated in Australia | The unit in your office |
| Who can read it | Provider staff and systems, under policy | Your staff, within the boundaries you set. The named Australian provider processes only permitted excerpts, under contract, and keeps nothing | Your staff only |
| Is it kept | On the provider’s terms | Kept on your instance; the provider is barred from retaining it | Stays on the unit |
| Can it train a model | On consumer tiers, yes | No, by contract | Only your own unit learns from it, on your hardware |
Part of Use cases in accounting firms. See how this works in practice: Client letters on Ermos.
Common questions
Do ChatGPT and Claude use the information in a director penalty notice advice letter?
Is it safe to paste a director penalty notice advice letter into ChatGPT or Claude?
Does deleting the chat remove a director penalty notice advice letter from ChatGPT or Claude?
How can an accounting firm use AI for a director penalty notice advice letter without sending it to ChatGPT or Claude?
What does a director penalty notice cover?
How long do directors have after a director penalty notice?
Does a payment plan stop a director penalty?
See Dominion answering from your own documents.
A demonstration takes 30 minutes, uses no client data, and comes with no obligation.
Book a demo